Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (2024)


Written By Kayla Lobermeier

Jump to Recipe

Is there a recipe that immediately makes you think of the month of November? Pumpkin pie is certainly that recipe for me! I have been making pumpkin pie for many years now. It was one of the first recipes that I learned how to make from scratch, and it was in fact the second recipe that I ever shared on our blog back in 2015! I love making pumpkin pie, and I feel that I will probably share a recipe for this old-fashioned American recipe every year.

This timeless pumpkin pie is made with a homegrown roasted pumpkin from our garden, delicious autumnal spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger, eggs, milk, and brown sugar. It’s an American staple at the Thanksgiving table that cannot be skipped!

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (1)

where did pumpkin pie come from?

Was pumpkin pie served at the first Thanksgiving. If you know anything about food history, you will know that the answer to this question is no. The early European settlers that were a part of the first Thanksgiving with the Indigenous Americans would have most likely made a pumpkin custard or pudding, if they ate any sort of dessert at all. This was made by mixing together a roasted pumpkin filling with sweetener and then baked inside of the pumpkin itself or earthenware dishes for many hours. It would have resembled the filling of the pumpkin pie we make today simply without the crust filling and the additional thickeners that give pumpkin pie its modern creamy texture.

However, I have made pumpkin pie from the 1800s, and the filling ingredients are quite similar to what we make today! You can read about my 1879 Bourbon Pumpkin Pie Recipe here.

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (2)

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (3)

tips for roasting pumpkin:

Roasting your own pie pumpkin is actually quite simple! While buying a can of pumpkin or pureed squash is much easier, it can be rather fulfilling to make the entire pie from scratch if you have the time. While roasting a pumpkin isn’t complicated, it does add an extra hour to your bake time.

Other than being fun to try every once in a while, it also adds incredible flavor to your pie. I hardly ever use canned pumpkin anymore because we grow our own pie pumpkins on our farm, but I also try my best to use my own homemade pumpkin puree because it taste better. A from-scratch pumpkin pie is life changing!

My best tip for working with real pumpkin is to use a pie pumpkin over any other type of pumpkin. Pie pumpkins are bred specifically for making pies with a smoother, finer flesh. This helps to prevent lumps from forming in your pie. A large jack-o-lantern style pumpkin can certainly be used, but you may not have as rich of a flavor and smooth of a texture. Butternut squash, acorn squash, kabocha squash, or sweet potatoes can also be used to make this pie!

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (4)

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (5)

tips for baking pumpkin pie:

  • Chill your pie crust. Make sure that when you make your pie crust, all of the ingredients are kept cold. The colder the butter, the better. This will help the ingredients to laminate, or form layers, and give the crust that flaky texture we all know and love. I prefer to use butter in my crust for pumpkin pie, but lard works just as well!

  • Use high quality ingredients. If you want a truly knock-out pie for your Thanksgiving dinner, use high quality ingredients. I recommend using farm-fresh eggs if you can get your hands on them and whole milk for a truly decadent filling. Freshly grated nutmeg is a game changer, too. If you cannot afford or find these ingredients right now, that’s okay!! It will still turn out amazing.

  • Let your pie cool in the oven. Have you made pumpkin pie before and had your filling crack while it was cooling? Pumpkin pie filling is a custard, which means it needs to cool down slowly. Rather than taking your pie out of the oven when the timer goes off, simply leave it in the oven, and turn off the heat. Let the pie cool in the oven for at least an hour before putting it on the countertop to finish cooling. If you are nervous about the crust over-browning, cover the pie with tin foil making sure that it does not touch the surface of the pie.

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (6)

final thoughts:

I love Thanksgiving! It’s my favorite holiday. I am sure that you can guess why. Even with all of the food, it is a time when we can all settle in and enjoy time spent with family. It’s a more wholesome version of the December holidays, I think, because it’s not necessarily about all of the presents and fancy decorations. It’s a time when we can simply join together and be present for a day with our loved ones.

I hope that you have fun making this historically inspired pumpkin pie. It’s a traditional autumn dessert that cannot be beat!

xoxo Kayla

Classic Pumpkin Pie

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (7)

Yield: 8-9

Author: Kayla Lobermeier

Prep time: 1 HourCook time: 3 HourInactive time: 1 HourTotal time: 5 Hour

Indulge in the timeless allure of my Classic Pumpkin Pie, a symphony of warm and cozy spices that encapsulate the essence of autumn. This recipe boasts the authenticity of real pumpkin, carefully blended with a medley of fall-inspired flavors. Nestled in a homemade flaky crust, each velvety slice is a testament to the art of traditional baking. The aromatic notes of nutmeg add a touch of nostalgia, while the recipe itself draws inspiration from history. Elevate your seasonal gatherings with the rich, comforting taste of this iconic dessert, bringing generations together around the table.


Flaky Pie Crust:

  • 1 1/4 cups (163 g) all-purpose flour
  • 1 tbsp (15 g) granulated sugar
  • 1/2 tsp kosher salt
  • 1/2 cup (116 g) butter or lard, cold and cut into 1/2-inch (1-cm) cubes
  • 4 tbsp (60 ml) ice cold water

Pumpkin Filling:

  • 1 to 2 medium pie pumpkins, or other winter squash such as butternut, honeynut, acorn, kabocha, or even sweet potatoes
  • 1 cup (220 g) brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup (33 g) all purpose flour
  • 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1/4 tsp ground ginger
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 1 cup (240 ml) whole milk or coconut milk
  • 4 large eggs
  • 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 cups (480 ml) pumpkin puree
  • 1/4 cup (60 ml) melted salted butter
  • 1 large egg + 1 tbsp (15 ml) water, for egg wash

Whipped Cream:

  • 1 cup (240 ml) heavy cream
  • 2 tbsp (30 g) granulated sugar


To make the Pie Crust:

  1. In a large bowl, whisk together the flour, sugar, and salt. Cut in the cold, cubed butter with a pastry blender or fork. Blend until the butter is completely coated in the flour mixture and resembles crumbs about the size of a pea.
  2. Slowly add in the water, 1 tablespoon (15 ml) at a time, until the crust just comes together with your hands. It should still be a bit crumbly. Knead the dough until it is more consistent, being careful not to over handle it and melt the butter. Shape the dough into a round disc and wrap it in plastic wrap. Refrigerate the dough for at least 1 hour or up to 2 days.

To make the Pumpkin Pie:

  1. Preheat the oven to 350° F (177° C) and line a large baking sheet with parchment paper.
  2. Slice the pumpkin(s) in half and scoop out the seeds and stringy center. Save these for later use. Place the pumpkin flesh-side down on the prepared baking sheet and roast the pumpkin(s) for about 50 to 60 minutes or until soft. The skin should be very flexible and already starting to pull away from the flesh.
  3. Remove the skins and place the pumpkin flesh into a blender or food processor. Pulse the flesh until it becomes smooth and pureed. Measure out 2 cups of pumpkin puree and set this aside for now. Alternately, you can use canned pumpkin or squash.
  4. Next, make the filling. In a large bowl, mix together the brown sugar, flour, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and salt.
  5. Add the milk, eggs, and vanilla. Beat until smooth. Fold in the pumpkin puree until combined. Add the melted butter and stir well, about 8 to 10 minutes total.
  6. Roll out the pie crust and shape it into a 10-inch (25-cm) pie pan. Trim the edges to about 1-inch (2.5-cm) overhang and fold the overhang under. Then, crimp the edges with your fingers. Poke the bottom of the crust all over with the tines of a fork. Brush the pie crust all over with the egg wash; for a nice thin coating add about 1 tbsp (15 ml) water and a pinch of salt to the egg wash.
  7. Pour the pumpkin filling into the crust. Bake the pie at the center of the oven at 350° F (177° C) for about 1 hour or until the center is set and slightly wobbly, a bit like Jell-O. Turn off the heat from the oven and let the pie cool down for another hour. This will help prevent the pie from cracking.
  8. Remove the pie from the oven and allow it to cool fully before covering with plastic wrap and chilling in the fridge. Otherwise, you can eat it at room temperature. If there are leftovers, the pie must be chilled and can be kept for about 4 to 5 days in the fridge.

To make the Whipped Cream:

  1. To make the whipped cream, combine the heavy cream and sugar in a large bowl. Beat the cream with an electric mixer or a whisk until it forms stiff peaks, about 5 to 7 minutes.
  2. Transfer the whipped cream to a piping bag fitted with a star tip. Pipe the whipped cream onto the pie before serving.


Apple Ginger Muffins with Cinnamon Streusel

Bakery Style Salted Caramel, Walnut, Chocolate Chunk Cookies

Classic Pumpkin Pie

Tangled Britches or 18th Century Dutch Crullers

Apple Butter Brioche Cinnamon Rolls

Pumpkin Coffee Cake with Cinnamon Ginger Streusel Topping

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (14)

pumpkin piepumpkinpumpkin pureeroasted pumpkinpiepie recipeautumnfallfall pieautumn pieautumn dessertfall dessertdessertdessertspumpkin pie fillinghistoryhistoricalhistorical recipehistorical christmasthanksgivingholidaysweetrecipesweetswhipped creamcream

Kayla Lobermeier

Kayla Lobermeier is an author, blogger, recipe developer, photographer, homesteader, and co-owner of the brandUnder A Tin Roofwith her mother, Jill Haupt. She lives in rural Iowa with her husband, children, and parents on their multi-generational family farm.Under A Tin Roofis a small flower farm and online lifestyle company focused on sharing the joy of seasonal, slow living with others who enjoy gardening, preserving, and cooking with wholesome ingredients. Kayla has been sharing her family’s journey into a simpler and sustainable lifestyle for almost a decade,andshehas been featured in publications such asWillow and Sage Magazine, Where Women Cook, Heirloom Gardener, Folk Magazine, In Her Garden, Beekman 1802 Almanac,andGardenista.She has taught cooking and gardening lessons through Kirkwood Community College andhashosted farm-to-table suppers at her family farm. You can usually find her sipping on a hot cup of coffee, reading up on the domestic lives of the Victorians, and snuggling with barn cats. Visit Kayla atwww.underatinroof.comor on Instagram and YouTube @underatinroof.

Classic Pumpkin Pie with a Historical Twist | Timeless Autumn Dessert Recipe — Under A Tin Roof (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nathanael Baumbach

Last Updated:

Views: 6596

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nathanael Baumbach

Birthday: 1998-12-02

Address: Apt. 829 751 Glover View, West Orlando, IN 22436

Phone: +901025288581

Job: Internal IT Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Motor sports, Flying, Skiing, Hooping, Lego building, Ice skating

Introduction: My name is Nathanael Baumbach, I am a fantastic, nice, victorious, brave, healthy, cute, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.